Overall Rating: 8.5/10
Summary: Alanna never was much one for magic, so it's a problem when her father sends her to a covenant to learn magic. Her twin look-alike brother, Thom, isn't exactly pleased either. He's being sent to Court to learn how to be a knight when he'd much rather be taught magic.
So the two twins come to the obvious solution.
Switch places.
This is a little more complicated than the initial idea. With the help of Thom's forgery skills and two of the household servants however, the two manage to work things out. Thom leaves with Maude, the village healing woman, for the covenant with his own name in the letter in place of Alanna's. He has no problem, as the covenant accepts males as well as females.
Alanna doesn't get off so easily.
She disguises herself as a boy and with the help of Coram, her manservant, she begins life in the Castle as a page. Alanna quickly learns that life in the Castle is hard, what with wrestling practice, chores, and studies, not to mention there's a bit of a bully problem. Even though she has Prince Jonathan, Raoul, Gary, Alex, and several other pages/squires on her side she refuses to accept their help in fighting the page, Ralon. She makes herself work hard, practicing with a heavy sword late into the night and going to her friends in the city for fighting tricks.
Alanna braves the Castle life, but is she able to keep her identity hidden? Does Ralon get the best of her? Will she be able to keep up with the other boys? Even Alanna isn't sure of the answers.
Opinion: This book doesn't waste time. The very first line introduces us to the problem that our characters are faced with. We meet Alanna and Thom right off the bat and get a feel for their personalities and current lives. Descriptions are short and to the point, a strong contrast to Pierce's later books such as the Trickster stories. At first I was annoyed by the short, choppy sentences and quick transitions, but after a little while I became comfortable with the style and even liked it. There was no waiting for action. There was little to no filler. The plot was quick paced and exciting.
It did take me a little while to sort out what name went with what character for a little while. All of the pages were introduced in the same page or so and descriptions got mashed up in my head, but as the book progressed they became more defined. They became easy to identify with and I began to care about what they did and what happened to them. Alanna herself is very easy to like. She's the underdog striving to be on top, doing everything within her power to get there. She never loses sight of her goal and manages to keep up with the boys, despite being smaller and in some cases, weaker.
Title: Like with Percy Jackson and Artemis Fowl: Not very creative, but descriptive and simple enough.
Cover: I'd expect nothing less from a fantasy book out of the 80s. Okay its not bad but it wouldn't stand out very much.
Series: I high recommend reading the remaining 4 books if you liked this one. The others are just as spectacular. :)
Recommendation: If you like medieval stories, magic, fantasy, and/or strong female protagonists you'd enjoy this. The word choice is a bit strange at first, but eventually you get used to the flow and can immerse yourself in the story. I'd say grades 5+
---
PS
Here's me with my Wednesday costume ;)



PS
Here's me with my Wednesday costume ;)
(Thanks to my friend Miranda for taking the top 2 pics, and my brother for the bottom!)
MJ
MJ